Best Overall
Hamilton Beach 2-Way 49980R
Key details
- Capacity
- 12 cups, glass carafe
- Footprint
- 12.2"W x 13.9"H
- Programmable
- 24-hour timer, bold and regular
- Single-Serve Brew
- Up to 14 oz
Two brew baskets live inside this machine — a mesh scoop for a single mug and a standard basket for the 12-cup carafe — and that is the reason it sits first on this list. Most households don't want one or the other; they want a pot on Sunday and a mug on Tuesday, and this is the rare machine at this price that does both from ground coffee. The scoop takes a measure of grounds, drops into the brew path, and rinses clean under the tap. No capsules, no reusable pod to pry open, nothing to reorder.
The single-serve side tops out at 14 ounces, which covers a mug and most commuter cups but not a 20-ounce insulated bottle — that one gets two rounds or the carafe. Programming is a straightforward 24-hour timer with bold and regular strengths, and AutoPause stops the flow long enough to pour a cup mid-brew without a puddle under the basket. In a house where two people leave at different times, that second basket earns its counter space.
The trade is footprint. At 13.9 inches tall and 12.2 inches wide it takes real counter, and the lid needs headroom to swing up, so measure the gap under your upper cabinets before you commit. The carafe is glass on a warming plate, which means a pot left on all morning tastes stewed by lunch — brew closer to what you'll drink and the plate stops mattering.
What we keep coming back to is how little upkeep the arrangement needs: a reusable basket on the single-serve side, a #4 paper filter in the pot side, and only one carafe to wash.
Pros
- Brews a 12-cup pot or a single mug from grounds
- No pods to buy, store or recycle
- 24-hour timer with bold and regular strengths
- AutoPause lets you pour before the pot finishes
Cons
- Single-serve side caps at 14 ounces
- Tall, wide body needs counter and lid clearance
The one we tell most people to buy: a full pot for the household and a single mug from the same grounds, with nothing pod-shaped to rebuy.