Best Overall
Mayflash F500
Key details
- Parts
- Sanwa-compatible lever and buttons
- Weight
- 6.55 lb
- Connection
- Wired USB
- Compatibility
- Switch, Xbox, PS4/PS3, PC, Android, Steam Deck
The F500 earns our top spot because it refuses to make you choose a console. It covers Switch, Xbox, PlayStation 4 and 3, PC, Android, Steam Deck, and a long list of mini consoles, and it does it with a single wired connection and a straightforward button layout. For a first serious stick, that flexibility matters more than a fancy finish: you can move it between a living-room console and a desktop PC without buying a second controller.
The 2.97 kg body is the other reason we keep coming back to it. It sits still on a desk or across your lap when you yank a quarter-circle, and the wide base leaves room for both hands. The case takes Sanwa-compatible parts, so you can swap in different parts later without replacing the stick. The turbo and headset support are useful extras on supported consoles, and we appreciate that Mayflash made the upgrade path obvious instead of sealing the case.
What it does better than any other pick is cover a mixed house of consoles without a second controller. If you want one sturdy, mod-friendly stick to learn on and keep, this is the one we point to first. If wireless is a priority, the 8Bitdo and F700 are the better fit.
Pros
- Works with nearly every major console
- Heavy base resists sliding
- Sanwa-compatible upgrade path
- Beginner-friendly controls and turbo
Cons
- PS5 requires a separate adapter
- Stock buttons are the first upgrade
We think most players should start with the F500: it covers more consoles than anything else here, stays put on a desk, and accepts Sanwa parts.