Best Overall
TP-Link TL-SG1005P
Key details
- Cooling
- Fanless
- PoE Ports
- 4 of 5
- PoE Budget
- 65W
- Port Speed
- Gigabit
Four inches square and an inch tall, in a metal case light enough to forget you are holding it: the TL-SG1005P is the switch we point most people to first, because it does the job and then gets out of the way. Four of its five gigabit ports carry PoE+ (802.3af/at, up to 30W each) on a 65W total budget, and the fifth is the uplink back to your router.
Nothing about it needs configuring. We plugged a camera and an access point into ours and both came up powered and passing video without a browser window ever opening. It also lists port-based QoS and IGMP snooping, which several of the cheaper PoE switches here skip, and that starts to matter once a few camera streams and a VoIP call share one uplink.
The 65W budget is the number to run your own arithmetic against. Four ordinary bullets drawing 5 to 10W each sit comfortably inside it; four PTZ domes near the 30W per-port ceiling do not, and no amount of port counting changes that. If your devices are on the heavy end, the 16-port TP-Link or one of the 190W boxes is the better fit.
What you give up is management: no VLANs, no per-port controls, no extend mode for long runs. For a house or a small shop hanging four cameras and an access point off one cable, none of it is missed. The wall-mount slots are the detail we appreciate most — two screws into a joist in the garage and the thing is off the shelf for good.
Pros
- Powers four devices plus an uplink on one box
- Fanless, so it adds no noise to a room
- Metal case at a plastic-switch price
- QoS and IGMP snooping the cheap ones skip
Cons
- No VLAN, management, or extend mode
- Only four of the five ports supply power
For four cameras or access points, this is the one to buy: silent, metal, gigabit, and the least expensive PoE switch here that manages all three.